Skip to main content
Praxikon

Direct answer · GDPR

Are standard contractual clauses on their own sufficient for a transfer?

Short answer

No. Standard contractual clauses are an appropriate safeguard for transfers (Article 46(2)(c)), but according to the Court of Justice in Schrems II the exporter must verify case by case whether the law of the third country ensures an essentially equivalent level of protection. If it does not, supplementary measures are needed, and otherwise the transfer must be suspended or ended.

Direct answer · GDPR

Standard contractual clauses and Schrems II

No. Standard contractual clauses are an appropriate safeguard for transfers (Article 46(2)(c)), but the Court of Justice held in Schrems II that the exporter must verify, case by case, whether the law of the third country ensures a level of protection essentially equivalent to that guaranteed in the EU. If it does not, supplementary measures are needed, and otherwise the transfer must be suspended or ended. The EDPB describes that assessment and the supplementary measures in Recommendations 01/2020.

For you to establish

  • To which country do the data go, and has the recipient excluded access by public authorities there?

Articles

Case law

  • Schrems II (CJEU, C-311/18, ECLI:EU:C:2020:559, 2020-07-16)Operative part: case-by-case assessment, supplementary measures or suspension.

Guidelines and decisions

Read the article Check your own case General interpretation, not legal advice. The official source remains authoritative.

Check your own situation

Describe your system or project in the free case check and get a reasoned first assessment of, among other things, the DPIA obligation, Article 22 GDPR and the AI Act, with the source for every conclusion.

Go to the free case check
Zahed Ashkara, jurist and freelance AI & Privacy Consultant

Behind this page

Zahed Ashkara

Freelance AI & Privacy Consultant, jurist