Ruling
Pankki S: when and why your file was consulted falls within the right of access, the names of employees in principle do not
- Date
- Status
- final
- Body
- Hof van Justitie van de EU (Eerste kamer), procedure ingeleid door J.M., in tegenwoordigheid van Apulaistietosuojavaltuutettu en Pankki S (verwijzing door de bestuursrechter Oost-Finland)
- Reference
- C-579/21, ECLI:EU:C:2023:501
What it is about
Question: is a bank customer entitled to information on who consulted his data, when and why, where the consultations took place before 25 May 2018 and he also worked at the bank? Ruling: Article 15, read with Article 99(2), applies to an access request made after 25 May 2018, even if the processing took place earlier. The dates and purposes of the consultations fall within the right of access; a copy of information from log files may be needed for that. The identity of the employees who consulted the data under the authority and instructions of the controller in principle does not; employees are not recipients. It is different where that information is essential to enable the data subject to exercise his GDPR rights effectively, taking into account the rights and freedoms of those employees. The fact that the bank carries out a regulated activity and that the customer was also an employee does not in principle affect the scope of the right.
What this means in practice
Record in your systems who consults a file, when and for what purpose, and make sure you can provide the dates and purposes in response to an access request. This also applies to logs of AI systems and to municipalities and banks that keep customer or resident files. You do not in principle disclose employees' names; if someone asks for them because he doubts the lawfulness, balance case by case and point where needed to the complaint route with the supervisory authority (Article 77).
The GDPR articles concerned
Source: EUR-Lex, arrest C-579/21checked on 17 November 2026
Summary and practical reading by Praxikon. Not legal advice; the source prevails.
Connections
What connects to this development
Themes where this returns
The counterpart in the other law
- Article 3 AI Act: Definitions
- Article 5 AI Act: Prohibited AI practices
- Article 6 AI Act: Classification rules for high-risk AI systems
- Article 14 AI Act: Human oversight
- Article 16 AI Act: Obligations of providers of high-risk AI systems
- Article 25 AI Act: Responsibilities along the AI value chain
- Article 26 AI Act: Obligations of deployers of high-risk AI systems
- Article 50 AI Act: Transparency obligations for providers and deployers of certain AI systems
- Article 86 AI Act: Right to explanation of individual decision-making
Case law8 of 14
- Lindenberg: a data protection authority is a controller towards the complainant and must grant access
2026-11-05 · final, Hof van Justitie van de EU (Derde kamer), Joachim Lindenberg tegen Bayerisches Landesamt für Datenschutzaufsicht
- IAB Europe: the TC String is personal data and the industry body is a joint controller
2024-03-07 · final, Hof van Justitie van de EU (Vierde kamer), IAB Europe tegen Gegevensbeschermingsautoriteit (België)
- Council of State: 600,000 euro fine for wifi tracking in Enschede stays annulled
2026-07-29 · final, Raad van State, Afdeling bestuursrechtspraak
- Brillen Rottler: even a first access request can be abusive if made solely to claim compensation
2026-03-19 · final, Hof van Justitie van de EU (Vierde kamer), Brillen Rottler GmbH & Co. KG tegen TC
- EDPS v SRB: pseudonymised data are not always personal data for everyone, but the information duty applies from collection
2025-09-04 · final, Hof van Justitie van de EU (Eerste kamer), Europese Toezichthouder voor gegevensbescherming (EDPS) tegen Gemeenschappelijke Afwikkelingsraad (SRB)
- Gelderland District Court: bankruptcy trustee is controller, DPA fine for unsecured hard drive cut to 58,125 euros
2025-08-07 · status not established, Rechtbank Gelderland
- Dun & Bradstreet: right to an intelligible explanation of an automated decision, trade secrets are no absolute ground for refusal
2025-02-27 · final, Hof van Justitie van de EU (Eerste kamer), CK tegen Magistrat der Stadt Wien, met Dun & Bradstreet Austria GmbH als andere partij
- Overijssel District Court revokes DPA fine for wifi tracking in Enschede
2024-02-02 · final, Rechtbank Overijssel
Guidelines
- Guidelines 07/2020 on the concepts of controller and processor in the GDPR
2021-07-07 · final, European Data Protection Board (EDPB)
- Dutch DPA (AP) publishes position paper on the Digital Omnibus and the AI Omnibus
2026-01-13 · final, Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens
- Guidelines on Automated individual decision-making and Profiling for the purposes of Regulation 2016/679
2018-05-25 · final, Article 29 Working Party, bekrachtigd door de European Data Protection Board (EDPB)
- Guidelines 02/2026 on Anonymisation
2026-07-07 · under consultation, European Data Protection Board (EDPB)
- Opinion 28/2024 on certain data protection aspects related to the processing of personal data in the context of AI models
2024-12-17 · final, European Data Protection Board (EDPB)
- Guidelines 05/2020 on consent under Regulation 2016/679
2020-05-04 · final, European Data Protection Board (EDPB)
- Guidelines 01/2025 on Pseudonymisation
2025-01-16 · under consultation, European Data Protection Board (EDPB)
- EDPB and EDPS adopt Joint Opinion 2/2026 on the Digital Omnibus
2026-02-10 · final, European Data Protection Board en European Data Protection Supervisor
Enforcement and fines
- EDPB picks automated decisions in recruitment as the topic of its 2027 coordinated enforcement action
2026-11-11 · adopted, European Data Protection Board (EDPB)
- Coolblue fined 40,000 euros on objection for cookies without consent
2024-12-23 · status not established, Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens
- Netflix fined 4.75 million euros for failing to properly inform customers
2024-11-26 · under appeal, Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens
- Clearview AI: 30.5 million euro fine and penalty orders for illegal facial database
2024-05-16 · final, Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens
- Dutch DPA: Tax Administration still falls short of the GDPR on 10 of the 12 topics reviewed
2026-11-11 · final, Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens
Legislation in motion6 of 9
- Proposal: relative definition of personal data (Article 4(1) GDPR)
2025-11-19 · proposal, Europese Commissie
- European Parliament: joint ITRE-LIBE draft report, amendments tabled, no committee vote yet
2026-06-22 · under negotiation, Europees Parlement, commissies ITRE en LIBE (gezamenlijke commissie)
- Proposal: refusing requests that abuse the right of access (Article 12(5) GDPR)
2025-11-19 · proposal, Europese Commissie
- Proposal: implementing acts on when pseudonymised data ceases to be personal data (new Article 41a GDPR)
2025-11-19 · proposal, Europese Commissie
- Council: Irish Presidency continues with a revised compromise, Antici Group 11 September 2026
2026-09-11 · under negotiation, Raad van de Europese Unie, Iers voorzitterschap
- Proposal: cookie rules move from ePrivacy to the GDPR, with new exceptions and a six-month rule (new Article 88a GDPR and Article 5(3) ePrivacy)
2025-11-19 · under negotiation, Europese Commissie
Analysis6 of 10
- The right to explanation under Article 86 of the EU AI Act: what a municipality must explain
2026-11-17
- Regulators will look at automated candidate screening in 2027: what to put in place now
2026-11-13
- Access to a complaint file: what the Lindenberg ruling means for your municipality
2026-11-13
- AI agents and the GDPR: what you need to arrange
2026-11-05
- Data breach in an AI system: notifying the supervisory authority and data subjects (Articles 33 and 34 GDPR)
2026-11-16
- Instructions for use of a high-risk AI system: what Article 13 of the AI Act requires and what you do with them
2026-11-17

Behind this page
Zahed Ashkara
Freelance AI and privacy consultant and legal adviser · AI governance & safety