Skip to main content
Praxikon

Ruling

Pankki S: when and why your file was consulted falls within the right of access, the names of employees in principle do not

Date
Status
final
Body
Hof van Justitie van de EU (Eerste kamer), procedure ingeleid door J.M., in tegenwoordigheid van Apulaistietosuojavaltuutettu en Pankki S (verwijzing door de bestuursrechter Oost-Finland)
Reference
C-579/21, ECLI:EU:C:2023:501

What it is about

Question: is a bank customer entitled to information on who consulted his data, when and why, where the consultations took place before 25 May 2018 and he also worked at the bank? Ruling: Article 15, read with Article 99(2), applies to an access request made after 25 May 2018, even if the processing took place earlier. The dates and purposes of the consultations fall within the right of access; a copy of information from log files may be needed for that. The identity of the employees who consulted the data under the authority and instructions of the controller in principle does not; employees are not recipients. It is different where that information is essential to enable the data subject to exercise his GDPR rights effectively, taking into account the rights and freedoms of those employees. The fact that the bank carries out a regulated activity and that the customer was also an employee does not in principle affect the scope of the right.

What this means in practice

Record in your systems who consults a file, when and for what purpose, and make sure you can provide the dates and purposes in response to an access request. This also applies to logs of AI systems and to municipalities and banks that keep customer or resident files. You do not in principle disclose employees' names; if someone asks for them because he doubts the lawfulness, balance case by case and point where needed to the complaint route with the supervisory authority (Article 77).

The GDPR articles concerned

Source: EUR-Lex, arrest C-579/21checked on 17 November 2026

Summary and practical reading by Praxikon. Not legal advice; the source prevails.

Connections

What connects to this development

The counterpart in the other law

Case law8 of 14

Guidelines

Enforcement and fines

Legislation in motion6 of 9

Zahed Ashkara, freelance AI and privacy consultant and legal adviser

Behind this page

Zahed Ashkara

Freelance AI and privacy consultant and legal adviser · AI governance & safety