Skip to main content
Praxikon

How the Commission keeps reviewing the AI Act: Article 112 on evaluation and review

··15 min read

"Is the AI Act set in stone?" No. Article 112 says how often the Commission reviews the rules. It creates no obligations for organisations, but what falls outside Annex III today may fall within it later.

In short

The Commission assesses once a year whether Annex III and the list of prohibited practices in Article 5 need amending, and evaluates the Regulation in fixed rounds, first by 2 August 2028 and 2 August 2029. The Digital Omnibus on AI (Regulation (EU) 2026/1744) did not amend Article 112. The first annual report, COM(2026) 234 of 20 May 2026, proposed no amendment of Annex III and noted a potential regulatory gap in the prohibitions, which the Commission is analysing further. We did not find a second annual report on 22 November 2026.

What Article 112 covers

Article 112 is addressed to the Commission: paragraphs 1 to 7 and 13 say what it assesses and when, the rest how. The Board, Member States and national competent authorities provide information on request (paragraph 8); the Commission takes into account the positions and findings of the Board, the European Parliament, the Council and other relevant bodies or sources (paragraph 9) and, if necessary, submits proposals for amendment (paragraph 10). The AI Office develops an objective and participative methodology for the evaluation of risk levels and the inclusion of new systems in Annex III, Article 5 and Article 50 (paragraph 11). Paragraph 12 concerns the sectoral legislation in Section B of Annex I; see the post on cars, aviation, rail and ships. The Board advises on this (Article 66, point (e)(ii) and (vii); see our post on the Board).

What the Digital Omnibus changed

Nothing in Article 112 itself. Regulation (EU) 2026/1744 lists its amendments to the AI Act in Article 1, in 43 points; Article 112 is not among them, and the text in the consolidated version of 27 July 2026 is identical to the 2024 text. Two amendments do touch it:

The annual assessment (paragraph 1)

"Once a year following the entry into force of this Regulation, and until the end of the period of the delegation of power laid down in Article 97", the Commission assesses the need to amend Annex III and the list of prohibited AI practices in Article 5, and submits its findings to Parliament and Council.

Which period? Article 97(2) confers the power for, among others, Article 7 for five years from 1 August 2024, tacitly extended unless the European Parliament or the Council opposes it at least three months before the end. Paragraph 1 does not say which period it means. In our reading it is the period for Article 7, since paragraph 1 concerns Annex III, and the assessment continues for as long as that delegation is extended. Another reading is that the assessment stops at the end of the first period, in August 2029; the Regulation does not say so expressly. See the post on Articles 97 and 98.

Two lists, two routes. Within the eight existing areas, the Commission can amend Annex III by delegated act, subject to the conditions of Article 7 and provided the European Parliament and the Council do not object (Article 97(6)); see the post on Articles 7 and 8. Article 5 may only be modified through a legislative amendment (COM(2026) 234, point 14).

The first report. COM(2026) 234 is the first report adopted under paragraph 1 (point 5). For Annex III the Commission proposed no amendment and flagged uses for further monitoring (points 45 and 46); it left the review of the area headings outside the report, as that is only due by 2 August 2028 (point 5). For Article 5, the majority of the Member States present saw no need at this stage (point 27). The Commission did note a potential regulatory gap regarding AI systems generating child sexual abuse material and non-consensual intimate content (point 61). Its page for the report refers to the Omnibus agreement of 7 May 2026, with such a ban.

The next report. According to point 63, the next assessment is due in 2026. On 22 November 2026 we did not find it: EUR-Lex returned only COM(2026) 234 for "Article 112(1) of Regulation (EU) 2024/1689", and since January 2026 the Commission library on digital-strategy.ec.europa.eu held only the page of 22 May 2026 on this subject. That does not mean none is under way.

All reporting dates in one table

DateWhat the Commission evaluates or reports onTo whomPublicParagraph
Once a year, from 1 August 2024 until the end of the delegation period in Article 97The need to amend Annex III and the list of prohibited practices in Article 5European Parliament and CouncilNot regulated in paragraph 1; the first report is on EUR-Lex, and the Commission says it will publish the next (COM(2026) 234, point 63)1
By 2 August 2028, then every four yearsExtending existing area headings or adding new ones in Annex III; amendments to the list of AI systems requiring additional transparency measures in Article 50; the supervision and governance system. With specific attention to the resources of national competent authorities, penalties and fines (Article 99(1)), harmonised standards and common specifications, and the number of new undertakings and SMEsEuropean Parliament and CouncilNot regulated2 and 4
By 2 August 2028The functioning, powers and resources of the AI OfficeEuropean Parliament and CouncilNot regulated5
By 2 August 2028, then every four yearsProgress on standardisation deliverables on the energy-efficient development of general-purpose AI models, and the need for further measures or actions, including binding onesEuropean Parliament and CouncilYes6
By 2 August 2028, then every three yearsImpact and effectiveness of voluntary codes of conduct for AI systems other than high-risk AI systems, including as regards environmental sustainabilityNot statedNot regulated7
By 2 August 2029, then every four yearsEvaluation and review of the whole Regulation, including the structure of enforcement and the possible need for a Union agency; where appropriate with a proposal for amendmentEuropean Parliament and CouncilYes3
By 2 August 2031Assessment of enforcement over the first years of application; where appropriate with a proposal on the structure of enforcement and a Union agencyEuropean Parliament, Council and European Economic and Social CommitteeNot regulated13
Not later than nine months before the end of each five-year period; for the period from 1 August 2024, by our calculation around 1 November 2028Report in respect of the delegation of powerNot statedNot regulatedArticle 97(2)

"Not regulated" means the paragraph is silent, not that the report is confidential. Recital 174 summarises paragraphs 1, 2, 3, 6 and 7.

The evaluations from 2028 (paragraphs 2 to 7)

Annex III and Article 50. Paragraph 2, point (a), covers what Article 7 cannot do: extending or adding an area heading, which requires a legislative amendment. Point (b) concerns the transparency obligations of Article 50; Article 97 confers no delegated power for it, so in our reading that too requires a legislative amendment. Article 50 has applied since 2 August 2026; generative systems placed on the market earlier have until 2 December 2026 for the marking under paragraph 2 (Article 111(4)). See enforcement and fines under Article 50.

Fines (paragraph 4, point (b)). The reports under paragraph 2, not the one under paragraph 3, look at the penalties applied by Member States, in particular administrative fines as referred to in Article 99(1). Since the Omnibus, that paragraph expressly mentions administrative fines and SMCs; warnings and non-monetary measures were already in the 2024 text. See our post on fines for municipalities.

Standards (paragraph 4, point (c)). A harmonised standard gives a presumption of conformity with the requirements of Section 2 of Chapter III and the obligations of Chapter V that it covers (Article 40(1)). Common specifications come only where standardisation falls short, no reference to a harmonised standard covering those requirements has been published, and none is expected within a reasonable period (Article 41(1)). The first one is EN 18286:2026 on quality management systems (Implementing Decision (EU) 2026/2274, published on 14 October 2026); the Decision does not say whether the presumption also covers the quality management system of Article 17. See the post on Articles 40, 41 and 42.

Other. Paragraph 6 ties in with the standardisation request of Article 40(2); paragraph 7 concerns the codes of conduct of Article 95.

Example 1: the municipality

A municipality uses a model that decides which residents with arrears in municipal taxes receive a reminder or an enforcement order first. The example is fictitious.

Not Annex III now. In our reading this falls outside Annex III: point 5(a) concerns essential public assistance benefits and services, not collecting taxes. If it also assesses tax remission or reclaims benefits, point 5(a) does come into view in our reading. With data from other contexts, the social scoring ban also comes into play.

Why Article 112 matters. The Commission monitors AI used in debt collection. Stakeholders pointed to its use by energy, telecom and financial providers, not public authorities; according to the Commission such AI could potentially fall under the area heading of points 5 or 8 (COM(2026) 234, point 46). Where a use falls under an existing heading and poses a risk equivalent to or greater than that of the listed use cases, the Commission can add it by delegated act (Article 7(1)). Whether collecting municipal taxes falls under point 5 or 8 is uncertain in our reading; if not, a legislative amendment is needed (paragraph 2(a)).

What the municipality records now. For each system: which point of Annex III it checked and why the system falls outside, the intended purpose, the data, how many residents are affected, whether staff can override the output and whether an enforcement order can be reversed. These are criteria of Article 7(2). The GDPR applies regardless: where processing is likely to result in a high risk, a data protection impact assessment is required beforehand (Article 35 GDPR, paragraph 1). Paragraph 3, point (a), requires it for a systematic and extensive evaluation of personal aspects based on automated processing, including profiling, on which decisions are based that produce legal effects or similarly significantly affect the person.

If it does become Annex III. The high-risk rules then apply from 2 December 2027 at the earliest, with the obligations of Article 26 and the fundamental rights impact assessment of Article 27, which may cross-refer to the data protection impact assessment (paragraph 4). As a public authority, the municipality registers itself and its use of the system in the EU database beforehand (Article 49(3), Article 26(8)). A system already placed on the market or put into service before 2 December 2027 only falls under those rules under Article 111(2) after significant changes in its design, and for public authorities by 2 August 2030 at the latest. For a use case added later this is not expressly regulated (see the transitional rules).

Example 2: the bank

A bank lets a model decide which customers in arrears on a consumer loan get which collection approach. Also fictitious. In our reading it falls outside point 5(b) of Annex III as long as the model is not intended to be used to evaluate creditworthiness or establish a credit score. If the bank also uses it for that, in our reading it falls under point 5(b). If the bank built the model itself, it is the provider (Article 3, point 3); if it modifies the intended purpose of a purchased system in that way, it becomes the provider (Article 25(1)(c)). Article 6(3) then offers no way out: a model that groups customers by payment behaviour performs, in our reading, profiling, and such a system is always considered high-risk (Article 6(3), last subparagraph). Stakeholders raised debt collection by financial providers (point 46), so the bank records the same as the municipality.

What you do now

  1. Record for each AI system which point of Annex III you checked and why it does or does not fall within it, with the criteria of Article 7(2) as fixed fields.
  2. Put the dates in your calendar: the annual report, 2 August 2028, 2 August 2029 and 2 August 2031.
  3. Keep your data protection impact assessment up to date; it supplies the facts for a later fundamental rights impact assessment.

The case check shows which AI Act and GDPR obligations apply to a use case.

Frequently asked questions about Article 112 of the AI Act

Newsletter

Every Tuesday, the AI Act week ahead in 5 minutes

A practical briefing on deadlines, new guidance and enforcement, so you know what matters this week. No spam and you can unsubscribe in one click.

Practical and short · No spam · One-click unsubscribe