Skip to main content
Praxikon

Experts of the scientific panel for the supervisor: Article 69 AI Act

··13 min read

Supervising AI takes expertise that not every national authority has in house. Article 69 gives the Member States a European route for this: they may call upon experts of the scientific panel of independent experts that the Commission set up under Article 68. How the panel itself is organised is covered in the scientific advisory layer of the AI Act. This piece is about access by the Member States. We work from the consolidated text of 27 July 2026, including the amendment made by the Digital Omnibus on AI (Regulation (EU) 2026/1744).

In brief

Member States may call upon experts of the panel to support their enforcement activities (paragraph 1). They may be required to pay fees for this, since the Omnibus at a rate equivalent to the remuneration fees applicable to the Commission (paragraph 2). The Commission facilitates timely access as needed and ensures that the support by the experts and by Union AI testing support (Article 84) is efficiently organised (paragraph 3).

An organisation that uses AI cannot request an expert of the panel itself. At most it notices the Article when its supervisor brings in an expert during an investigation.

The Article has applied since 2 August 2025 (Article 113, point (b)).

What Article 69 provides

Paragraph 1: access. Member States may call upon experts of the panel to support their enforcement activities under the AI Act. According to recital 151, this allows the reinforcement of national capacities necessary for effective enforcement.

Paragraph 2: fees. Already under the original text the Member States could be required to pay; that text left the structure and level of fees and the scale and structure of recoverable costs to the implementing act referred to in Article 68(1). That act, Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/454 of 7 March 2025, contains no fee arrangement for the Member States; we checked the text for this. The Omnibus replaced paragraph 2. What is new is the yardstick: fees "at a rate equivalent to the remuneration fees applicable to the Commission pursuant to the implementing act referred to in Article 68(1)". Recital 30 of Regulation (EU) 2026/1744 describes this as simplifying the fee structure.

The implementing regulation does not state an amount. Experts are remunerated in accordance with the provisions in force at the Commission when they have been appointed as rapporteur or contributor for tasks requested by the AI Office (Article 9 of Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/454). Which rate a Member State pays is not settled in the sources we read. The amendment entered into force on 27 July 2026; because Chapter VII already applied, in our reading it has effect from that date.

Paragraph 3: the role of the Commission. The Commission facilitates timely access to the experts by the Member States, as needed, and ensures that the combination of support activities carried out by Union AI testing support under Article 84 and by the experts is efficiently organised and provides the best possible added value.

Panel, pool and testing support

A national supervisor can obtain European technical support by three routes. In our reading they differ as follows:

RouteWho asksWhat it provides
Article 68(3), point (b)The market surveillance authoritySupport of its work by the panel
Article 69The Member StateExperts of the panel for enforcement
Article 84(2)The Board, the Commission or a market surveillance authorityIndependent technical or scientific advice from a Union AI testing support structure

The implementing regulation also keeps the first two apart. The Secretariat of the panel, provided jointly by the AI Office and the Joint Research Centre, processes requests from market surveillance authorities to the panel for additional expertise as well as requests from Member States for support by experts for their enforcement at national level (Article 6 of Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/454).

For requests from market surveillance authorities there is a procedure (Article 14 of Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/454). The request may only concern market surveillance activities under the AI Act, states its purpose and substantiates its necessity and proportionality. The AI Office evaluates this, taking into account the available capacity of the panel and the necessity of ensuring effective access to experts for all Member States. It processes the request within two weeks from receipt of the full request. If the request is accepted, the Commission appoints a rapporteur and two contributors; a refusal states the reasons.

The implementing regulation does not say expressly whether a request under Article 69 follows the same steps. Recital 9 of Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/454 does link the reinforcement of national capacities to requests from market surveillance authorities, through the practical means of the AI Office; in our reading, Article 14 is therefore the practical route.

Confidentiality

An expert who is brought in may see trade secrets or personal data. The experts ensure confidentiality, perform their tasks with impartiality and objectivity, and neither seek nor take instructions from anyone (Article 68(4)). Article 78 binds everyone involved in the application of the AI Act, among other things to protect trade secrets, source code, inspections and investigations; in our reading an expert who is brought in is covered. For personal data, data protection law continues to apply as well (Article 2(7) of the AI Act). In addition, the experts sign a declaration of confidentiality, are bound by Article 339 TFEU and may have no employment or contractual relationship with a provider of AI systems or general-purpose AI models (Articles 10 and 13 of Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/454). Opinions and recommendations of the panel are published, except where this would entail the disclosure of confidential business information, trade secrets or strategic interests of the Union (Article 12 of that regulation).

Who asks in the Netherlands

For the high-risk AI systems in Annex III, no market surveillance authority has yet been designated by law in the Netherlands. For products in Section A of Annex I it is in principle the authority under the product legislation (Article 74(3)). The draft bill for the Dutch AI Act Implementation Act (Uitvoeringswet AI-verordening) was open for public consultation until 1 June 2026; submission to the House of Representatives is planned for the second quarter of 2027 (Parliamentary Paper 26643, no. 1554). For high-risk AI systems in Annex III, the draft designates, among others, the Dutch Data Protection Authority (Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens, AP) for point 5(a), and the AFM, DNB and the AP for point 5(b) and (c); a ministerial regulation limits that last designation to categories of operators (Article 2.2(1)(c) and (2) of the draft). It is not yet law. For high-risk AI systems of financial institutions, the AI Act itself designates the financial supervisor, in so far as the placing on the market, putting into service or use is directly connected with the provision of the financial services (Article 74(6)); a Member State may derogate from this (Article 74(7)).

We found no provision on the panel in the draft bill. Under Article 3.9 of the draft the supervisor may, however, charge the operator concerned for the costs of its action, at amounts set by ministerial regulation. The draft does not say whether a fee for an expert of the panel falls under that.

What an organisation notices

A municipality. Suppose it is 2028. That year a supplier places on the market a system that evaluates whether applicants are eligible for social assistance, and a municipality puts it into use. That falls under Annex III, point 5(a), and is in principle high-risk; the requirements apply to such systems from 2 December 2027 (Article 113, point (c)(i)). If the system was already placed on the market or put into service before that date, the Regulation applies only after a significant change in its design; for systems intended to be used by public authorities, provider and deployer must comply by 2 August 2030 at the latest (Article 111(2)). The supplier is the provider, the municipality the deployer; as a public authority it registers the use in the EU database beforehand (Article 49(3) and Article 26(8)). After complaints, the supervisor, under the draft the AP, investigates whether the system disadvantages certain groups, and asks an expert of the panel to assess the supplier's test results. The example is fictional.

In our reading the municipality notices little of this:

  • The questions still come from the supervisor. Article 69 gives the expert no powers of their own; the supervisor's powers are in Article 74 and Regulation (EU) 2019/1020.
  • What the municipality provides may reach the expert. It can ask the supervisor who will see the documents and for what purpose, and mark confidential parts as such. That pays off: an opinion of the panel may be published, except in so far as it contains confidential business information or trade secrets.
  • The expert's view is advice; the supervisor takes the decision.

What the supervisor may request is covered in market surveillance powers; what follows if it finds a risk, in the procedure of Articles 79 to 82.

A bank or insurer. A bank uses a model that evaluates the creditworthiness of natural persons (Annex III, point 5(b)), or an insurer a model for risk assessment and pricing in health insurance (point 5(c)). Both are in principle high-risk, subject to Article 6(3). If the bank builds the model itself and uses it under its own name, it is both provider and deployer (Article 3, points (3) and (4)). The financial supervisor can use the same route for a technical assessment. This example is fictional too. In our reading it pays to write the technical documentation so that an outside expert can follow it without explanation, and to identify trade secrets right away.

What is settled and what is not

Settled: Articles 68 and 69 have applied since 2 August 2025, Article 84 since 2 August 2026, and Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/454 has been adopted. According to the Commission, 60 experts have been selected for a 24-month term, with a chair and a vice-chair (AI Act Scientific Panel). We have not established whether a Member State has already called upon experts or which rate a Member State pays. On 19 November 2026 we found no designated Union AI testing support structure; how we searched is set out in our piece on Article 84. That we did not find it does not mean it does not exist.

The role of the panel for general-purpose AI models is covered in Commission supervision of general-purpose AI models; the implementing regulation also appears in our overview of delegated and implementing acts.

Frequently asked questions about Article 69 of the AI Act

Newsletter

Every Tuesday, the AI Act week ahead in 5 minutes

A practical briefing on deadlines, new guidance and enforcement, so you know what matters this week. No spam and you can unsubscribe in one click.

Practical and short · No spam · One-click unsubscribe

Written by

Zahed Ashkara, freelance AI and privacy consultant and legal adviser

Zahed Ashkara

Freelance AI and privacy consultant and legal adviser · AI governance & safety

Zahed Ashkara is a freelance AI and privacy consultant and legal adviser for the GDPR and the EU AI Act. Organisations hire him as AI governance consultant, privacy counsel, external DPO or AI governance lead, have him carry out a DPIA, FRIA or AI Act classification, or book an in-company training. He focuses on AI governance and safety, including AI agents. He works exclusively as a freelancer, through Embed AI (trade name Praxikon). He is a Certified AI Compliance Officer (CAICO) and has been a member of the NEN standards committee Artificial Intelligence & Big Data since July 2026.

Follow on LinkedInView expert profile

Use these sources in your AI assistant too: Praxikon in Claude and other assistants

Real-World Stories

Discover how organizations apply this in practice

Related articles

How a general-purpose AI model is classified as a model with systemic risk: Article 52 of the AI Act

Article 52 of the AI Act sets out how a general-purpose AI model becomes a model with systemic risk: notification within two weeks, counter-arguments from the provider, designation by the Commission ex officio or following a qualified alert from the scientific panel, reassessment upon request and a published list. What each paragraph says, how Article 51 and Annex XIII come in, and what a municipality, bank or university of applied sciences building on such a model will notice.

EU AI ActArticle 51Article 52

The EU AI Office: what it does and when it supervises your organisation

The European Commission's AI Office enforces the rules for general-purpose AI models and is exclusively competent for two groups of AI systems, a competence that the Digital Omnibus extended and specified (Article 75(1) AI Act). For most municipalities, banks and employers it is not the supervisor of their own duties. When it is, when it is not, and what to arrange now.

EU AI ActAI OfficeArticle 75